Choosing the best car seat for your toddler can be tricky.
There are many brands out there, and with such varying quality and mixed reviews, it can be incredibly time-consuming to search for a car seat for your child.
Fortunately, I've sifted through many different car seat options online, so you don't have to. As a father of two and experienced babysitter, I've seen my fair share of car seats.
Through my research and testing, I've found the best car seat for 3-year-old toddlers is the Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 Car Seat.
While the Extend2Fit model boasts the best all-around options, there are other reasons to consider more specialized options. Continue reading below as we discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each model tested.
What Car Seats Are Suitable for a 3-Year-Old?
So the first thing to consider when looking at different car seats for your three-year-old is the criteria. What makes a car seat suitable for a three-year-old?
Safety is the most important thing to look for in your child's car seat.
The entire purpose of a car seat is to protect your child in the event of an accident or even just a hard stop.
Car accidents are one of the leading causes of death or injury for children, so it makes sense that we'd want to minimize that as much as possible.
When looking for a car seat for your toddler, check its safety ratings. One thing to look out for is if the label says it meets the federal motor vehicle safety standard 213.
This ensures that the seat has been verified and is up to code.
Another thing to ensure is that you know how to set up a car seat. It might look easy on paper, but one missed installation step can lead to injury or, worse, an accident.
If a model looks too complex for you to handle, consider choosing a simpler one or asking an expert how to install it.
The last thing to note is that three-year-olds should utilize front-facing seats.
As you may already know, smaller babies will use a rear-facing car seat. Once your child's head and the top of that rear-facing seat are longer than 1 inch (.025 meters) apart, they are ready to transition to the front-facing car seat.
If your child has not already transitioned from a rear-facing seat to a front-facing seat, measure this distance to see if they are ready before purchasing.
Cheap Car Seats
Saving money is good, especially when you have a child who requires much of your support. That's why the Evenflo Maestro Sport Harness Booster Car Seat is such a great option.
This particular option is excellent because it comes at a lower price than most other car seats without sacrificing all of the quality.
The features of this model include carrying a lightweight seat, a small size, and even a triple-layered cushion.
While there are cheaper options than this one model, it is essential not to skimp out entirely on a car seat.
While the most expensive model is not required, it is important that you make sure your car seat is FMV-approved and functions correctly.
After all, going too cheap will result in a low-grade, dysfunctional seat.
Foldable Car Seats
A good option for a foldable car seat for a three-year-old is the WAYB Pico Travel Car Seat with Standard Carrying Bag. This option is good because it can fold inward.
This feature makes the product much more compact, and its light weight makes it a really easy option to carry around.
Foldable car seats are a great option for those busy bees who plan on taking their seat between cars or on the go.
Car Seat Law
Car crashes and accidents are the leading cause of death and injury in children ages one to 13. While a lot of this is because young children are in good health and don't die from many other things, it doesn't negate the fact that car crashes threaten children.
This is why car seats and boosters are required in every state in the United States.
Your child is required to sit in a car seat as long as they are under the age of eight or under 57 inches (1.44 meters) tall. Children three years or younger must be in the rear seat.
Failure to follow these laws will result in a $10 fine if they are under four years or a $25 fine if above that. Upon further violation, you will be punished more so.
Once children reach the age of eight or are 57 inches (1.44 meters) tall, they can start using a seatbelt. Your three-year-old won't have to worry about this for a few years.
11 Best Car Seats for 3-Year-Olds
Now that we've got some introductory information out of the way, let's discuss the eleven best car seats for a three-year-old.
1. Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 Car Seat
This model features almost all of the best features you could want from a car seat, and it was a pleasure to look into this one for today's list.
The Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 Car Seat is easily the best car seat for three-year-old children.
The biggest boon to this model is its 3-in-1 functionality. This car seat can be morphed into a rear-facing seat, a forward-facing seat, and a booster seat. This is incredible, as you would usually have to buy these three seats separately over time.
While this product might seem pricier than other options on the list today, it is functionally three different seats. Under this guise, it's much cheaper than buying three different seats separately. Not to mention it saves some hassle from shopping two other times.
Another stand-out feature of this model is the extension panel. There is a bar that can slide out of the bottom of the chair to extend the legroom of the seat. This additional footrest is a nice plus and helps to keep your child fitting in their chair longer.
The chair is also made of soft material that children love. I've found that both my toddlers conk right out when using this seat.
Overall, the Graco Extend2Fit 3 in 1 Car Seat is the best option, and anyone who can invest in their car seat should definitely consider it. It is truly the premium option.
Pros
- Three options including a rear-facing seat, forward-facing seat, and a booster seat
- The chair features an extension panel
- The cover is machine washable
Cons
- Booster form can't remove back
- Heavy
2. Graco 4Ever DLX 4-in-1
The Graco 4Ever model does exactly what the name promises. It lasts forever. Never have I seen a car seat so customizable and long-lasting, and it continues to impress me to date.
This model features a convertible car seat that can be used in all four forms. Most car seats don't need durability because you'll only be using them for a year or two apiece. The 4Ever model is great because it can shape as your child needs to jump between different car seats.
The only reason this seat loses out to the Extend2Fit model is that the seat is a bit narrow. While the all-in-one is excellent because it is so versatile, I have found that it makes the seat more difficult for larger children.
But overall, this model is a terrific option, and anyone who wants to buy one and be done with it should consider this seat. You may very well never have to buy a car seat again.
Pros
- Four options, including a rear-facing seat, a forward-facing seat, a booster seat, and a backless booster
- Highly durable
Cons
- Heavy and inconvenient for travel
- A bit narrow horizontally
3. Graco Tranzitions 3-in-1
As you can probably tell by now, Graco is the top dog for car seats. The Tranzitions 3-in-1 Harness Booster Seat is another reason this company stays on top.
This is yet another seat that boasts a rear-facing, front-facing, and a backed booster seat as one model. It remains just as convenient on this seat as with both the 4Ever DLX and Extend2Fit.
The Graco Tranzitions even have a lower price than comparable car seats.
The major downside, however, is that this seat is incredibly complicated to convert. While you will only have to swap this car seat two or so times, it can be unnecessarily complex. Those who plan on using this for multiple kids might want to save the hassle and avoid this one.
This seat also has a giant sticker on the back of the chair. Visually, this is no big deal, but the sticker is air-tight and makes the chair hard to cool down. This can be frustrating when trying to keep your child comfortable, especially if you live in a warmer area.
Pros
- Three options including a rear-facing seat, forward-facing seat, and a booster seat
- Relatively cheap
Cons
- Seat gets warm
- Complicated to convert
4. Evenflo Maestro Sport Harness
While most three-year-olds aren't quite large enough to sit in a booster seat, they will make the jump soon enough. Not to mention that this seat is too good to pass up a mention.
The Evenflo Maestro Sport Harness Booster Car Seat is good because it offers a high-quality booster seat without raising the price.
This model is lightweight and soft, so it doesn't compromise functionality either.
Consider this budget option if your child is about to jump into a booster seat. It may help in your battle to stay on budget.
Pros
- Cupholders
- Lightweight
- Lower price
Cons
- Most three-year-olds aren't large enough for a booster seat, yet
5. Safety 1st Guide 65
The Safety 1st car seat is great because of its highly compact design. The seat is both small and highly durable, making it the best choice for a smaller vehicle.
This seat is also reasonably cheap with easy installation.
The only negative I have to say about this one is that it can be a bit heavy for travel, but not nearly as much so as some other seats.
Pros
- Highly compact seat
- Lower price
- Easy to Instal
Cons
- Slightly heavy
6. Britax Boulevard Clicktight
The seat can also morph from a rear-facing car seat to a front-facing one. Alongside the adjustable height, this seat is incredibly versatile and long-lasting.
Next up, we have the Britax Boulevard ClickTight Anti-Rebound Convertible Car Seat. This car seat stands out by being highly customizable dimensions.
This seat is easily able to adjust its height to allow children to grow alongside the chair.
Not to mention that you won't have to buy a separate seat for rear and forward facing.
The only major downside to this model is its size. While the model's greatest strength is its large size and high weight limits, it also makes the seat quite heavy and clunky.
This is a terrific option for those seeking an adjustable size, but beware if you plan on moving the seat around a lot.
Pros
- Adjustable seat to accommodate the size
- Large weight limit
Cons
- A significant weight limit results in a heavier seat
- Not the softest padding
7. Diono Radian 3R All-in-One
I think the Diono Radian is the best option for the multipurpose seats on today's list. The chair features an appealing design on a seat that is both swappable and easy to set up.
The chair can fold and isn't too heavy, so it isn't the most difficult to move. However, the chair is oversized and eats up a lot of room in the car.
The larger size can also make the chair more awkward to move around.
Pros
- Three chairs in one
- Easy to set up
Cons
- The chair is large
8. Baby Trend Trooper 3-in-1
The Baby Trend Trooper is easily the most comfortable seat on the market. This seat is highly padded and offers the finest comfort a car seat can provide.
The seat also boasts a stylish design, featuring one of the more colorful options in both pink and red.
The seat is a 3-in-1, but I find that the rear-facing option is a super awkward fit.
It can be challenging to squeeze the chair into my car when I have it facing backward. But besides that minor gripe, this car seat is suitable for its comfort and high quality.
Pros
- Stylish design
- Highly padded for maximum comfort
Cons
- The rear-facing mode makes for an awkward fit
9. Baby Trend Hybrid 3-in-1
As you might imagine, some children outgrow their car seats earlier than others. This can be a significant issue, as you need the proper type of seat for your child's size.
This Baby Trend model excels at compensating for an early-growing child.
While many models can be outgrown by your toddler over time, this model is built to continue supporting long-term.
This car seat can hold a child up to almost 100 pounds or 45 kilograms at maximum capacity.
Consider this option if you think your child will outgrow their current seat in the near future. It can save you time and a hassle in the long run.
Pros
- Highly durable
- Comfortable padding
- Lightweight and portable
Cons
- Can be difficult to put together
10. Graco TriRide 3-in-1
As the last Graco entry on this list, the TriRide leaves on a high note. This seat is the safest option for your child overall, and that is the foremost goal of a car seat.
While this seat is a bit heavy and difficult to carry around, the TriRide 3-in-1 makes safety its foremost priority, passing inspections for the most rigorous testing available by Graco.
These include rollover, frontal, side, and even rear collisions.
While these aren't things I like to think about as a parent, it does bring me comfort to know this chair will maximize my toddler's safety.
Pros
- Highly durable
- High weight limit
Cons
- Heavy
11. Wayb Pico Travel Car Seat
On top of easy movement, this car seat allows you to forgo the top tether. This is impressive, as many older foldable models require this extra tether to keep your child in place.
The Wayb Pico Travel Car Seat promises a tight and compact car seat that folds to save space. After using this product, I can verify that what the company has set out to do is valid.
This Wayb Pico folds inward, and its lightweight exterior makes it quite simple to move around.
The lack of the top tether is nice, but know that it isn't a massive seller outside of Asia, Africa, or South America. Most North America, Europe, and Australian cars feature easy-to-use top tethers.
A significant downside to this model is the short height. While car seats aren't built for giants, this particular seat caps out reasonably low at 45 inches (or 1.143 meters).
This is pretty low and means you are always one growth spurt away from needing a new seat.
Overall, the Wayb Pico is well made and is an excellent choice for those looking to swap Uber cars a lot, but it is undoubtedly a more specialized option.
Pros
A foldable, compact seating
Approved by FAA for flight travel
Easy to use and install
Cons
Expensive
Lower maximum height
Concluding Thoughts
The best car seat for three-year-old toddlers is the Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 Car Seat. While other more specialized options are available, the Graco Extend2Fit does the most right.
I hope you have enjoyed these reviews and no matter what car seat you choose, make sure your three-year-old is in the right car seat for them.
Leave a Reply