• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Safe Convertible Car Seats

MENUMENU
  • Safety Laws
    • Alabama
    • Alaska
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • California
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Hawaii
    • Idaho
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Kentucky
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Minnesota
    • Mississippi
    • Missouri
    • Montana
    • Nebraska
    • Nevada
    • New Hampshire
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • North Carolina
    • North Dakota
    • Ohio
    • Oklahoma
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Rhode Island
    • South Carolina
    • South Dakota
    • Tennessee
    • Texas
    • Utah
    • Vermont
    • Virginia
    • Washington
    • West Virginia
    • Wisconsin
    • Wyoming
  • Learn
    • Types of Car Seats
    • Car Seat Stages
    • Federal Safety Standards
    • What's a Convertible Car Seat?
    • How to Choose
      • Infant vs Convertible
    • Car Seat Expiration Guide
    • Get Your Seat Checked
    • Safest Places for Car Seats
    • Toddler Unbuckling Car Seat
    • Accessories & Clothing Safety
      • Infant Car Seat Safety Accessories
      • Car Seat Head Support Safety
      • Car Seat Protector Safety
      • Car Seat Strap Covers Safety
    • Buying Used Car Seats
    • Safest Cars
  • Brands
    • Britax
      • Advocate ClickTight Review
      • Allegiance Car Seat Review
      • Boulevard ClickTight Review
      • Emblem Review
      • Marathon Clicktight Review
      • Marathon vs Advocate vs Boulevard
      • One4Life Review
      • Britax vs Chicco
      • Accessories
      • Expiration
      • Installation & Care
    • Chicco
      • Fit4 Review
      • NextFit Zip Review
      • Nextfit Sport vs Britax Marathon
    • Clek
      • Fllo Review
      • Foonf Review
      • Foonf vs Fllo
    • Cosco
      • Apt 50 Review
      • Mighty Fit 65 Review
      • Scenera Next Review
      • Installation & Care
    • Diono
      • Radian vs Rainier
      • Radian RXT Review
      • Radian 3QXT Review
      • Radian 3RXT Review
      • Radian 3RX vs Radian 3R
      • Rainier 2AX Review
      • Accessories
      • Installation & Care
    • Evenflo
      • EveryStage Review
      • Sonus Review
      • SureRide Review
      • Symphony DLX Review
      • Symphony LX vs DLX
      • Tribute Review
      • Triumph LX Review
      • Accessories
      • Installation & Care
    • Graco
      • 4Ever Review
        • 4Ever Tutorial
      • Contender 65 Review
        • Contender 65 Tutorial
      • Extend2Fit Review
      • Extend2Fit vs 4Ever
      • Milestone Review
        • Milestone Tutorial
      • My Ride 65 Review
        • My Ride 65 Tutorial
      • Sequence Review
      • Size4Me 65 Review
        • Size4Me 65 Tutorial
      • SlimFit Review
        • Slimfit Tutorial
      • Expiration
      • Installation & Care
    • Maxi-Cosi
      • Magellan Review
      • Pria 85 Review
      • Pria 85 vs 3-in-1
      • Accessories
      • Installation & Care
    • Peg Perego
    • Safety 1st
      • Continuum Review
      • Guide 65 Review
      • Grow and Go Review
      • MultiFit EX Air Review
      • Grow and Go vs Graco 4Ever
      • Accessories
      • Installation & Care
  • Buyer's Guides
    • Safest Car Seats (Top 30)
    • Best for Small Cars
    • Best for Budget
    • Best for Newborns
    • Best for Travel
  • Free Car Seats
    • Medicaid
    • WIC
    • Recycling & Donation
  • About Me

Infant Car Seat vs Convertible Car Seat: Safety, Tips for Choosing & More

January 5, 2021 by Sam Webster Leave a Comment

Infant Car Seat vs Convertible Car Seat

For new parents, having a baby can be an exciting and joyous, yet stressful experience. Before having the baby, parents will spend many days making sure that they have everything they need to keep their baby safe and comfortable. One of the most important of these essentials is deciding what car seat to use.

If you’re not sure what you’re looking for, buying a car seat can be an overwhelming task and can spark questions that you didn’t even know needed answering. For example, what’s an infant car seat? What’s a convertible car seat? What’s the difference between the two? How do I decide which car seat I need? I mean, aren’t they all technically the same?

This article will strive to provide detailed answers to these questions so that when you buy your first car seat, you can feel confident in that decision. At the end of the article, I’ll also answer frequently asked questions regarding if one type of car seat is safer than the other and how to tell when to transition your little one from one to the other.


Table Of Contents
Infant Car Seats
What is an Infant Car Seat?
How Safe Are Infant Car Seats?
Why Choose an Infant Car Seat?
What to Look for in an Infant Car Seat
Convertible Car Seats
What is a Convertible Car Seat?

How safe are convertible car seats?
Why Choose a Convertible Car Seat?
What to Look for in a Convertible Car Seat
FAQs: Infant Car Seats vs Convertible Car Seats
Infant Car Seats vs Convertible Car Seats by Babylist
Conclusion

Infant Car Seats

source

What is an Infant Car Seat?

An infant car seat is a rear-facing car seat that’s designed for infants and toddlers. Most of them typically have a maximum weight limit ranging from 22 to 35 pounds. Usually, infant car seats are the first type of car seat that parents will start with.


Infant car seats are comprised of two parts: the infant carrier and the base. The infant carrier can be easily removed from the base and installed into strollers and rockers so that you don’t have to carry the carrier around all of the time. Also, most infant car seats are designed to be universal devices, meaning that the infant carrier can be attached to bases other than its own. This makes it easier to transfer your car seat from car to car without going through the hassle of uninstalling your car seat.

How Safe Are Infant Car Seats?

If they’re being used correctly and have been installed properly, infant car seats can be very safe to use. I won’t go as far as to say that it’s safer to use than any other type of car seat, but they’re pretty safe when they’re used right.


According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, infant car seats should only ever be used in the rear-facing position. It’s also strongly recommended that you bring your child home from the hospital in an infant car seat. Once your child has reached or exceeds the height and weight requirements outlined by your car seat manufacturer, that will be the only time that they should transition to a forward-facing car seat.


Where infant car seats can become unsafe is when parents use the infant carrier for anything other than transporting their little one from one place to another. One of the most common mistakes that new parents make with infant car seats is leaving their child in the carrier for too long. Infant carriers should NOT be used for sleeping, feeding, or any other purpose outside of transportation.


In an article on Today, a mother recounted the tragic story of losing her 13-month old daughter who passed away due to falling asleep in her car seat. When a child falls asleep in their infant car seat, they’re falling asleep at a reclined angle, which can cause Positional Asphyxia - a situation where the baby’s airways are cut off due to their sleeping position.


As I said earlier, if they’re being used correctly, then infant car seats can be a great and safe way to get your baby from point A to point B.

Why Choose an Infant Car Seat?

While infant car seats come highly recommended due to their rear-facing only positioning, as I mentioned in the previous section, they’re extraordinary convenient. For one, infant car seats can easily detach from its base. So, unlike almost every other type of car seat, you don’t have to uninstall an infant car seat in order to move it. If you’ve ever had to uninstall a car seat, then you understand the hassle and frustration that comes with it. Infant car seats get rid of all of that negativity.


In addition to that, most infant car seats are designed to fit different types of bases. So, not only can they be removed easily, but they can also be installed in different vehicles. With infant car seats, it’s convenience on top of convenience, which is why most parents choose them as opposed to rear-facing convertibles (we’ll get into what those are in a bit).

What to Look for in an Infant Car Seat

When purchasing an infant car seat, there are several key factors that you’ll want to keep your eye out for. They include but are not limited to:

  • LATCH: LATCH stands for Lower Anchor Tether for Children, and it’s an easier, and some might say safer, way to install your car seat without using the vehicle seat belt. Most car seats today are manufactured to be compatible with the LATCH installation system. If you notice this as a feature, it’s a good sign that your car seat is up to date with the most recent car seat safety practices.
  • Safey Features: Some infant car seats are outfitted with special safety features, like anti-rebound bars or leveling systems that help you determine if the car seat is installed at the proper recline angle. Safety features like these provide an added measure of safety to the car seat, so they’re important things to keep your eye out for when looking for one.
  • Comfort: Making sure that your baby is comfortable is always an important thing to do. Infant car seats without adequate head and body support may warrant adding accessories to the car seat to make it comfier for your little one. When looking for a car seat, browse the features to make sure that it has ample padding to keep your baby snug and cozy.

Convertible Car Seats

source

What is a Convertible Car Seat?

Unlike infant car seats, a convertible car seat can be used in both the rear-facing and forward-facing positions. Most convertible car seats have a maximum weight limit of 65 pounds or more, so they can be used from the time you leave the hospital until it’s time to transition your child to a forward-facing booster seat.


When going from the rear-facing to forward-fsacing position, it’s important that you abide by the height and weight requirements that are outlined in your car seat manual. Also, keep in mind that if your child meets the minimum height and weight requirements, it doesn’t necessarily mean that they’re ready to sit in the forward-facing position.

How safe are convertible car seats?

Like any other car seat, convertible car seats are very safe if they’re used and installed correctly. However, a common mistake that most parents make when using a convertible car seat is transitioning their baby from the rear-facing to the forward-facing position too early. Doing this can put your little one at risk of serious injury, so you should know, without a shadow of a doubt, when you should convert your car seat.


Generally, you should follow your car seat manufacturer’s recommendation for when to transition your child to the forward-facing position. According to Safe Kids Worldwide, children should ride in the rear-facing position until they’ve met the maximum height and weight requirements. In addition to that, most car seat experts will tell you that your child should ride in the rear-facing position for as long as possible because, as an infant/toddler, it’s the safest way your baby can ride.

Why Choose a Convertible Car Seat?

Car seats can be pretty expensive, and having to buy more than one can run hundreds to thousands of dollars. What’s great about convertible car seats is that they’re with you for a long time, so you don’t have to worry about buying a new car seat after your child has outgrown their infant car seat. And, they’re made to last until your child enters the last stage of their car seat, meaning you won’t have to buy a new car seat for, potentially, years.


Also, because convertible car seats can be used from infancy, most of them are engineered with a surplus of safety features to accommodate infants, toddlers, and small children. You can rest assured knowing that your child will have everything they need to feel comfortable and secure while riding in the car.

What to Look for in a Convertible Car Seat

If you’re interested in purchasing a convertible car seat, here’s a few key factors that you should look for:

  • LATCH: Almost all convertible car seats are designed to be compatible with the LATCH installation system. If you’re interested in a convertible car seat, but you notice that it doesn’t feature LATCH, I would honestly recommend moving on to another seat.
  • Safey Features: There are very distinct safety features that you should look for when buying a convertible car seat. The safest ones are the ones with a steel-reinforced frame, a five-point harness, and extra layers of side impact protection.
  • Size: Because most convertible car seats are larger, a common mistake that parents make is buying one that doesn’t fit in their car. Measure the length and the width of the seat that you’ll be using to install the car seat, and then look for a convertible car seat that can fit within those parameters.

FAQs: Infant Car Seats vs Convertible Car Seats

What’s the difference between an infant car seat and a convertible?

  • Infant car seats are equipped with a detachable base. Convertible car seats are comprised of a single piece and don’t come with a base.
  • Most infant car seats come with a sun canopy to keep the sun out of their baby’s eyes. Convertible car seats can be equipped with a sun canopy, but they won’t come with one.
  • Infant car seats can only be used in the rear-facing position, while convertible car seats can be used in both the rear-facing and forward-facing positions.

Are infant car seats safer than convertible car seats?

I wouldn’t necessarily say that infant car seats are safer than convertible car seats. At the same time, I also wouldn’t say that convertible car seats are safer than infant car seats. Both can be equally safe when used correctly, which is why it’s important to follow the height and weight requirements that your car seat manufacturer has outlined.

When to switch from infant car seat?

You should transition from an infant car seat only after your child has met or exceeded the height and weight requirement of their seat. Most children will ride in an infant car seat until they’re at least one year old. While that may be true, please refer to your car seat manual for the height and weight requirements for your car seat.

Infant Car Seats vs Convertible Car Seats by Babylist

Conclusion

Buying a car seat can be a daunting task, but with the right information, it can be an easy-going experience.


Infant and convertible car seats are the most popular type of car seats, and as a parent, knowing the difference between the two is vital in making sure that your child rides in the car safely.


Remember, your child should ride in the rear-facing position for as long as possible, and you should only transition to a forward-facing convertible car seat once your child meets the maximum height and weight limits of their infant car seat.


If you have any more questions regarding transitioning your child from an infant to a convertible car seat, please contact your car seat manufacturer.

Sam Webster

With two kids of my own, I’m passionate about child safety! I’m a research nerd who’s on a mission to make the world a safer place for kids – starting with car seats!

To contact me directly please click here.

Filed Under: Learn

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Hey! I’m Sam, mom of Sadie and Xavier.

When I started searching for a convertible car seat I was overwhelmed by the choices out there.

But being a research nerd, I relished the challenge of finding the best seat for my needs. And in the process, I gathered a ton of info!

Read More About Me

SafeConvertibleCarSeats is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

  • Safety Laws
  • Learn
  • Brands
  • Buyer’s Guides
  • Free Car Seats
  • About Me