Our Top 3 Picks:
Finding the safest convertible car seat for your little ones can be challenging, because manufacturers claim that their seats are THE safest, and it can be hard to fact-check to see who's telling the truth.
On top of that, if you don't have that much experience, then you probably don't know what it takes to make a safe convertible car seat.
But fear not - in this article, we've done the work for you!
We've compiled a list of the top 30 safest convertible car seats. By the end of this guide, not only will you have a (proven) list of the top safe car seats, but you'll also learn which resources are legit and provide actual crash test results, and you'll also learn what features you should look for in a safe convertible car seat.
Methodology: How We Ranked The Safest Convertible Car Seats
To find the convertible car seats with the best safety results, we spent dozens of hours reviewing crash test results and safety ratings from the top credible sources, including
Each of these organizations conducts extensive and detailed crash-testing that determines everything from how well the side impact protection holds up in a collision to how easy it is to use and install/uninstall the car seat.
After reviewing each test result, we spent hours comparing them to double-check their accuracy and create this list in order - from the absolute safest convertible car seat, on down.
Each of these car seats (minus a select few that we identify), have their NHTSA ease of use ratings listed so that you can see why and how a car seat earned its place in this list.
Top 30 Safest Convertible Car Seats Ranked
Our Rating: 95
Chicco NextFit Zip Max Safety Rating
The Chicco NextFit Zip Max has some of the best crash test results from Consumer Reports. It received very high marks for ease of installation with both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH, and it was recognized for being easy to use.
CSFTL (Car Seats for the Littles) recommends the NextFit Zip Max for its ease of use features and extended rear-facing weight range.
The crash test results from Baby Gear Lab showed that the NextFit Zip Max significantly exceeds the federal minimum safety guidelines set by the FMVSS 213. These results showed high rankings in comfort, ease of installation using both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH, as well as above-average marks for its ease of use.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Installation Features: | 3 stars | 4 stars |
Securing the Child: | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Summary of Chicco NextFit Zip Max
The Chicco NextFit Zip Max is designed to make your child’s car seat riding experience safer and more comfortable. It provides up to 25% more legroom in the rear-facing position so that your child can sit comfortably with plenty of breathing/wiggle room as they grow. To add to its comfort, the NextFit Zip Max comes with a 3D breathable air mesh backrest that wicks away moisture. It also features a 9-position ReclineSure Leveling System that helps you accurately install your car seat at the proper angle. The NextFit Zip Max is also rigged with a SuperCinch Tightener and LockSure Belt Locking System that makes both LATCH and seatbelt installation quicker, easier, and more secure.
The combination of the SuperCinch and LockSure is what sets this car seat apart from the rest. Also, its extended rear-facing weight range, as well as the 25% more legroom it provides makes this model more popular than the previous Chicco car seats.
Pros & Cons of Chicco NextFit Zip Max
Pros
Cons
Who is the Chicco NextFit Zip Max best for?
The Chicco NextFit Zip Max is best suited for parents who are looking for a safe and reliable car seat that can be installed effortlessly with no hassle. If you have the budget and you don’t mind the weight of the car seat, then this car seat will be of great use to you until it’s time for your child to transition to a belt-positioning booster. I’d also recommend this car seat for children who are taller or have long legs.
Video Overview of Chicco NextFit Zip Max
Our Rating: 90
Britax Marathon Clicktight Safety Rating
The Britax Marahon ClickTight is highly recognized for its outstanding crash test results from Consumer Reports, receiving high marks for its ease of installation in both the rear-facing and forward-facing positions.
The Wirecutter named the Marathon ClickTight their “Top Pick” for the safest convertible car seat due to its ease of installation features, side-impact crash test results, ease of use, and extended rear-facing weight range.
The Marathon ClickTight received high yet below average ranks for its crash test results from Baby Gear Lab. Compared to their competitors, they scored below average for meeting the minimum federal guidelines for car seat safety. However, the crash test results also showed high marks in ease of installation for both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH, ease of use, and comfort.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Installation Features: | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Securing the Child: | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Summary of Britax Marathon ClickTight
The Marathon ClickTight features Britax’s revolutionary ClickTight installation system that makes installation quicker and easier while also providing a safe alternative to the limitations of LATCH. With the ClickTight system, you’ll be able to install your car seat in just three simple steps. The Marathon ClickTight is equipped with a Quick-Adjust 14-position harness that can be easily adjusted to create a more comfortable fit as your child grows.
It also comes with seven recline angles and an automatic level indicator that ensures that you install your car seat at the proper angle correctly. As an added measure of comfort, the Marathon ClickTight is outfitted in plush fabrics and foam padding that’s easily removable and machine-washable.
Pros & Cons of Britax Marathon ClickTight
Pros
Cons
Who is the Britax Marathon ClickTight model best for?
The Marathon ClickTight is a high-rated car seat that’s ideal for parents looking for a high-quality, safe, and easy-to-use car seat. The ClickTight system enhances the ease of installation, it’s made with plush padding to maximize your child’s comfort, and it has a lifespan of 10 years, meaning it’s long-lasting and reliable. This car set will be a breeze to use, and it’s highly recommended as a safe convertible car seat.
Video Overview of Britax Marathon ClickTight
Our Rating: 85
Britax Boulevard ClickTight Safety Rating
The Boulevard ClickTight is one of the highest rated convertible car seats on Consumer Reports. It got high marks for its installation features in both the rear-facing and forward-facing positions, overall ease of use, and comfort and quality.
Baby Gear Labs crash test results for the Boulevard ClickTight showed that it meets and exceeds the minimum federal safety regulations. It received high marks for its ease of installation using both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH, ease of use, and comfort.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Installation Features: | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Securing the Child: | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Summary of Britax Boulevard ClickTight
The Boulevard ClickTight revolutionizes installation with Britax’s innovative ClickTight Installation System. It makes it so that you can easily install your car seat in three simple steps while bypassing the limitations of LATCH. It comes with a Quick-Adjust 14-position headrest that can be easily adjusted without rethreading it to ensure a comfortable fit as your child grows. For secure installation, the Boulevard ClickTight has seven recline angles and an automatic level indicator that helps you install the car seat correctly at the proper angle. As an added measure of comfort, the Boulevard ClickTight is outfitted with plush foam padding and premium fabrics that are easy to remove and machine-washable.
Pros & Cons of Britax Boulevard ClickTight
Pros
Cons
Who is the Britax Boulevard ClickTight
model best for?
The Boulevard ClickTight is best suited for parents who have a difficult time installing their car seats. It eliminates the hassles of LATCH installation, and it offers a secure way to install your car seat correctly. It’s easy to use, easy to clean, and has a 10-year lifespan, so it’ll last for most of your child’s harnessed car seat riding experience.
Video Overview of Britax Boulevard ClickTight
Our Rating: 83
Britax Advocate ClickTight Safety Rating
The Advocate ClickTight is in the top percentile of safe convertible car seats rated by Consumer Reports. It’s recognized for its easy-to-use installation features in both the rear-facing and forward-facing positions and overall ease of use.
Baby Gear Labs crash tests showed that while the Advocate CLickTight does meet and exceed the federal minimum safety guidelines, it doesn’t provide any extra margin of protection despite its additional safety features. It got high marks for its easy installation using both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH, overall ease of use, and comfort.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 3 stars | 5 stars |
Installation Features: | 3 stars | 4 stars |
Securing the Child: | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Summary of Britax Advocate ClickTight
The Advocate ClickTight is another Britax model that utilizes their well-known ClickTight Installation System. This system eliminates the hassles of car seat installation and reduces it to just three easy steps. The Advocate ClickTight is also equipped with a Quick-Adjust 14-position headrest that can be easily adjusted as your child grows, and you don’t need to rethread it to adjust it. There are seven recline positions and an integrated automatic level indicator to help you install the car seat at the proper angle correctly. It also uses plush foam padding and premium fabrics to maximize comfort and make clean-up quick and easy.
Pros & Cons of Britax Advocate ClickTight
Pros
Cons
Who is the Britax Advocate ClickTight
model best for?
The Advocate ClickTight is ideal for parents that are looking for an easy-to-install car seat that comes with extra safety features. Its three layers of side impact protection offer additional safety and support for your child’s neck and head, and the ClickTight installation system provides a quick, easy, and secure way to install your car seat.
Video Overview of Britax Advocate ClickTight
Our Rating: 80
Britax Allegiance Safety Rating
Consumer Reports gave the Allegiance 3 Stage an average score with high high marks for ease of installation in the forward-facing position and overall ease of use.
CSFTL recommends the Allegiance 3 Stage for being long-lasting, easy to install, and easy to use.
Baby Gear Lab ranked the Allegiance Stage 3 very high after its exemplary crash test results. Out of their entire review of convertible car seats, the Allegiance earned the Best Head Sensor (HIC) results. In addition to that, it's recognized for being easy to install with both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH, easy to use, comfortable, and lightweight.
There are no NHTSA safety ratings for the Allegiance 3 Stage at this time.
Summary of Britax Allegiance
The Allegiance 3 Stage is rigged with a 10-position harness that can be easily adjusted to provide a comfortable fit for your little one. It comes with lower anchors that lock into place and can be easily released with the push of a button. The Allegiance 3 Stage is also equipped with built-in lock-offs to make seat belt installation quick, easy, and secure. In addition to that, there are three recline positions so that you can install your car seat correctly and at the most comfortable angle. For added comfort, the Allegiance 3 Stage also comes with a removable body pillow to help your child feel snug and at peace in their car seat.
The built-in lock-offs and lower anchors are what make the Allegiance 3 Stage stand out. Combined, these features make installation with LATCH and a vehicle seatbelt easy and simple.
Pros & Cons of Britax Allegiance
Pros
Cons
Who is the Britax Allegiance model best for?
The Allegiance 3 Stage is best suited for parents who are on a budget, want an easier way to install their car seat, and specifically want a Britax car seat. Britax is known for having relatively expensive car seats, and the Allegiance Stage 3 offers the same high-end features as these other seats but at a fraction of the price. Also, their installation features make installing a car seat quick and hassle-free.
Video Overview of Britax Allegiance
Our Rating: 80
Britax Emblem Safety Rating
Consumer Reports gave the Emblem an average safety score and commends it for its extra safety and comfort features. It’s recognized for being easy to install in the forward-facing position and easy to use overall.
CSFTL recommends the Emblem for its enhanced features, long-lasting design, and overall ease of installation.
Baby Gear LAB recognizes the Emblem for its excellent crash test results and stated, “The Emblem handily beat the higher-end Britax seats." It scored high for its ease of installation using both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH, ease of use, and comfort, and quality.
There are no NHTSA safety ratings for the Emblem at this time.
Summary of Britax Emblem
The Emblem features a 10-position no-rethread harness that can be easily adjusted as your child grows. It comes with lower anchors and built-in lock-offs to make both LATCH and seatbelt installation more efficient. There are three recline incline angles so that you can install the car seat at the angle that feels the most comfortable for your little one. The Emblem is outfitted in an easy-remove cover that’s machine-washable, and for added comfort, it’s also equipped with a removable body pillow that keeps your baby snug and cozy.
What makes the Emblems stand out are its enhanced installation features and overall ease of use. Also, its lightweight design makes this car seat easy to carry and transport from one vehicle to another.
Pros & Cons of Britax Emblem
Pros
Cons
Who is the Britax Emblem model best for?
The Emblem will work best for parents on a budget who want an easy-to-use car seat. Its safety features are enhanced and easy to navigate, and its long-lasting design ensures that this is the only car seat you’ll need for a while. Its lightweight design also makes the Emblem an ideal car seat for parents who travel a lot.
Video Overview of Britax Emblem
Our Rating: 77
Evenflo SureRide DLX Safety Rating
Consumer Reports awards the SureRide DLX an above-average score with a high ranking for its ease of installation in the forward-facing position. It’s also recognized for being easy to use and affordable.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 3 stars |
Securing the Child: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 3 stars | 2 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 2 stars | 1 stars |
Summary of Evenflo SureRide DLX
The SureRide DLX is designed with an extended rear-facing weight range so that your little one can ride safely for longer. It comes with six shoulder strap positions so that your child always has a comfortable fit as they grow. The harness includes an upfront harness adjustment and buckle release so that adjusting the car seat is quick and easy. In addition to that, the SureRide DLX has an ultra-lightweight and compact design, making it easy to carry and install, and the LATCH system makes it even easier to install. For comfort, the DLX is equipped with an energy-absorbing foam liner that also provides an added layer of safety.
The extended rear-facing weight range and ultra-lightweight design make the SureRide DLX stand out among the rest. It weighs less than 10 pounds, making it one of the lighter convertible car seats available on the market.
Pros & Cons of Evenflo SureRide DLX
Pros
Cons
Who is the Evenflo SureRide DLX model best for?
If you travel a lot, then the SureRide DLX is the car seat for you. Its lightweight design not only makes it easy to carry, but it also makes it easy to install. In addition to that, it’s compact enough that frees up enough room for more car seats and backseat passengers, so your whole family can travel with you.
Video Overview of Evenflo SureRide DLX
Our Rating: 73
Graco My Ride 65 Safety Rating
The My Ride 65 receives a below average score from Consumer Reports after undergoing extensive crash tests. The results showed high marks for easy forward and rear-facing installation, and moderate marks for its overall ease of use.
CSFTL recognizes and recommends the My Ride 65 for its ease of use, reasonable price, and extended rear-facing weight range.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Installation Features: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Securing the Child: | 5 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Summary of Graco My Ride 65
The My Ride 65 is designed to keep your child in the rear-facing position longer as recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics. It’s been extensively crash tested and meets and exceeds the federal safety standards. The My Ride 65 is LATCH-equipped and comes with an easy-to-read level indicator to ensure that you install the car seat correctly. It has a 5-point front-adjust harness that’s very easy to adjust. Additionally, the My Ride 65 comes with a removable infant insert and toddler headrest to provide added comfort for your little one.
What makes the My Ride 65 stand out is the extended rear-facing weight range and reasonable price.
Pros & Cons of Graco My Ride 65
Pros
Cons
Who is the Graco My Ride 65 model best for?
The My Ride 65 is best suited for parents on a budget who want to be sure that their car seat. With the My Ride 65’s extensive crash tests, we can see that it easily meets and exceeds the federal safety regulations for a reasonable price.
Video Overview of Graco My Ride 65
Our Rating: 72
Evenflo Sunos Safety Rating
The Sonus receives a below average safety score from Consumer Reports due to its subpar rear-facing installation features. However, the Sonus earns high marks for its ease of installation in the forward-facing position.
CSFTL recommends and praises the Sonus for its long-lasting design, reasonable price, comfort and quality.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 4 stars |
Securing the Child: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 2 stars | 1 stars |
Summary of Evenflo Sunos
The Sonus is designed to comfortably fit your child and vehicle. Its compact design can fit three across, and it has an extended base that can seat children in the rear-facing position longer. The base is also ergonomically designed to comfortably and securely fit your vehicle’s seat. The Sonus features a built-in airflow ventilation system that keeps your little one cool and dry no matter the season. It’s also equipped with an up-front adjust harness that has 5 harness positions to ensure a snug fit as your child grows.
The airflow ventilation system sets the Sonus apart, as well as its extended rear-facing weight range and ergonomically designed base. These features combined create a comfortable, safe, and secure car riding experience for your little one.
Pros & Cons of Evenflo Sunos
Pros
Cons
Who is the Evenflo Sunos model best for?
The Evenflo Sonus is ideal for families that travel a lot and live in warmer places. Its lightweight and compact design make it easy to carry through the airport. And, with the built-in air ventilation system, your child will always remain cool, dry, and comfortable. It’s also affordable, so it’s suited for parents on a budget.
Video Overview of Evenflo Sunos
Our Rating: 70
Graco Extend2Fit Safety Rating
The Extend2Fit scores high from Consumer Reports with an excellent ranking for its ease of installation in the rear-facing position using LATCH.
The Extend2Fit is highly praised by CSFTL for its ease of use, ease of installation, and extended rear-facing weight range. It’s recommended for its compact design and convenient features, such as the dual cup holders.
The Wirecutter names the Extend2Fit as the Runner-up for the best convertible car seat. It’s recognized for being easy to install with moderate to low side-impact crash test results. However, it’s commended for its extended rear-facing weight range and compact, lightweight design.
The Extend2Fit is one of Baby Gear Labs' highest-ranked car seats due to its excellent crash test results and overall ease of use. It’s also ranked high for its ease of installation using both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Installation Features: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Securing the Child: | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 5 stars | 3 stars |
Summary of Graco Extend2Fit
The Extend2Fit has a 50-pound rear-facing weight limit which is 10 pounds higher than most convertible car seats go. It’s equipped with a 4-position extension panel that can be used to create more legroom for your little one in the rear-facing position. The Extend2Fit also comes with a SimplySafe Adjust harness that can be easily adjusted to comfortably fit your child as they grow.
It also features an InRight LATCH system with a one-second attachment so that installation is quick and easy. In addition to that, it comes with an easy-to-read level indicator to ensure that you install the car seat correctly. To make getting your little one in and out of the car seat easier, the Extend2Fit has Fuss Free Harness Storage to secure the harness straps out of the way.
The 4-position extension panel is one of many features that make the Extend2Fit along with the SimplySafe Adjust harness and the InRight LATCH system. Not to mention the convenient Fuss Free Harness Storage that makes it easier to get your child in and out of their car seat.
Pros & Cons of Graco Extend2Fit
Pros
Cons
Who is the Graco Extend2Fit model best for?
The Extend2Fit is best suited for parents who want to keep their little one seated in the rear-facing position longer. It has a four-position extension panel so that your child can sit in the rear-facing position comfortably and has a higher extended rear-facing weight limit of 50 pounds, so it’s specifically designed to keep your child seated that way longer.
Video Overview of Graco Extend2Fit
Our Rating: 70
Evenflo Symphony Safety Rating
Consumer Reports gave the Symphony a decent score with an excellent ranking for its ease of installation if the forward-facing position using LATCH. It also received high marks for ease of installation in the rear-facing position, as well, and overall ease-of-use.
There are no NHTSA safety ratings for the Symphony at this time.
Summary of Evenflo Symphony
The Evenflo Symphony has been rated the #1 convertible car seat in Consumer magazine. It’s one of the first all-in-one car seat models and has a maximum weight limit of 110 pounds. The Symphony utilizes Quick-Connector technology to make installation quick, easy, and secure. It also comes with the patented Infinite Slide Harness that easily slides to provide a comfortable fit for your little one, so you don’t have to rethread it to adjust it.
What sets the Symphony apart from the rest is its multiple car seat positions and high weight limit of 110 pounds. Also, its enhanced safety features make it easy to use and easy to install.
Pros & Cons of Evenflo Symphony
Pros
Cons
Who is the Evenflo Symphony model best for?
The Symphony is best suited for parents who don’t want to waste money or time on more than one car seat. Its high weight limit of 110 pounds means that it can be used until your child outgrows the need for a car seat. The Symphony is also equipped with enhanced safety and installation features that will keep your child protected and comfortable for their entire car seat journey.
Video Overview of Evenflo Symphony
Our Rating: 69
Graco Contender 65 Safety Rating
The Contender 65 receives an above average score from Consumer Reports. It earns an excellent rank for its ease of installation in the forward-facing position using latch while also earning high marks for its overall ease-of-use.
CSFTL recommends the Contender 65 for its ease of installation and overall ease-of-use. It also acknowledges its extended rear-facing weight limit and long-lasting design.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Installation Features: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Securing the Child: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 5 stars | 4 stars |
Summary of Graco Contender 65
The Contender 65 is designed to keep your child seated in the rear-facing position longer. It’s equipped with the SimplySafe Harness system that automatically adjusts to your child’s growing height. It’s also rigged with a LATCH system and an easy-to-read level indicator to ensure that you install your car seat at the proper angle correctly. For comfort, the Contender 65 comes with a head and body support pillow to keep your little one snug and cozy every time they ride in the car.
What sets the Contender 65 apart is its self-adjusting harness that ensures a comfortable fit as your child grows. In addition to that, it comes with easy-to-use safety features that make installation quick and simple.
Pros & Cons of Graco Contender 65
Pros
Cons
Who is the Graco Contender 65 model best for?
If you’re looking for an affordable car seat that’s easy to use, then the Contender 65 is the choice for you. Its self-adjusting harness provides a comfortable fit for your growing child, and it’s so easy to adjust that you can do so with one hand. And, it’s less expensive than most convertible car seats available on the market today.
Video Overview of Graco Contender 65
Our Rating: 69
Graco 4Ever Safety Rating
The 4Ever 4-in-1 receives a high score from Consumer Reports with good marks for ease of installation, overall ease of use, and booster capabilities.
Csftl recommends the 4Ever 4-in-1 for its outstanding performance in each position it has to offer. It's also recognized for being very easy to use, long-lasting, and well-designed.
Baby Gear Labs crash tests showed that the 4Ever 4-in-1 has higher-than-average results, meaning it drastically exceeds the federal minimum safety guidelines. Compared to its competitors, the 4Ever 4-in-1 provides added measures of safety to ensure that it's safe to use. Additionally, it received high marks for its ease of installation using both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Booster NHTSA safety ratings |
|---|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 4 stars | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 3 stars | 5 stars |
Securing the Child: | 5 stars | 5 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 5 stars | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Summary of Graco 4Ever
With its 10-year lifespan the 4Ever 4-in-1 can be used from the moment you leave the hospital until your child outgrows the need for a car seat. The 4Ever 4-in-1 is equipped with a SimplySafe Adjust harness system that comes with a 10-position headrest that can be easily adjusted without rethreading the harness. There are six recline positions so that your child is seated at the proper and most comfortable angle, and the InRight installation system makes it so that you install the car seat correctly. The 4Ever 4-in-1 is engineered with a steel-reinforced steel frame that provides superior strength and durability.
Like most of the Graco car seats, what sets the 4Ever 4-in-1 apart is the SimplySafe harness system that can be quickly and easily adjusted without rethreading it. But, what gives the 4Ever 4-in-1 its edge its 10-year lifespan that makes it the only car seat you’ll ever need.
Pros & Cons of Graco 4Ever
Pros
Cons
Who is the Graco 4Ever model best for?
The 4Ever 4-in-1 is best suited for parents who want a car seat that’ll be a first and only investment. Its low minimum and high maximum weight limits mean that your child can use this seat for its entire car seat journey. Also, it comes with enhanced installation features that’ll last and make it easier to install your car seat.
Video Overview of Graco 4Ever
Our Rating: 69
Graco Milestone Safety Rating
Consumer Reports gives the Milestone 3-in-1 an above average score for its ease of installation and overall ease-of-use in each position it offers.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Booster NHTSA safety ratings |
|---|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 3 stars | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Securing the Child: | 5 stars | 5 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 5 stars | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Summary of Graco Milestone
The Milestone 3-in-1 offers three car seat positions, so you can use it from the moment you leave the hospital until your child outgrows the need for a car seat. It’s equipped with the SimplySafe Adjust harness system that can be easily rethreaded with just one hand. To help your child ride in the rear-facing position comfortably, the Milestone 3-in-1 comes with a 4-position extension panel that provides more legroom for your little one. It also comes with the InRight latch system to ensure that you install your car seat securely and at the proper angle.
For added convenience and comfort, the Milestone 3-in-1 is also rigged with an integrated harness storage compartment and removable plush inserts to keep your child snug and cozy. What sets the Milestone 3-in-1 apart is its multiple car seat positions and widely known SimplySafe Adjust harness system.
Pros & Cons of Graco Milestone
Pros
Cons
Who is the Graco Milestone model best for?
The Milestone 3-in-1 is best suited for parents who are looking to make a one-time investment for a high-quality car seat with convenient and enhanced safety features. Its installation system makes installing your car seat as easy as 1,2,3, and its safety features will provide up to ten years of use for your child.
Video Overview of Graco Milestone
Our Rating: 67
Cosco Scenera NEXT Safety Rating
Consumer Reports gives the Scenera NEXT an average score for its overall ease of use and standard safety and installation features.
CSFTL recommends the Scenera NEXT for its reasonable price, lightweight design, and extended rear-facing weight range.
The Scenera NEXT is mentioned by Wirecutter as one of the best convertible car seats for meeting and exceeding Federal safety guidelines, being easy to install and use, and having an extended rear-facing weight range.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 3 stars |
Securing the Child: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Summary of Cosco Scenera NEXT
The Scenera NEXT is simplistically designed to provide the ultimate protection for your little one. It’s equipped with a five-point harness and comes with three buckle positions to ensure a comfortable fit as your child grows, The Scenera NEXT has a compact design, so you can easily fit three in your backseat, or take it with you on your travels. To reduce the hassles of cleanup, the Scenera NEXT is outfitted with an easy-to-remove seat pad that’s machine-washable and dryer-safe.
It’s compact, lightweight design and reasonable price make the Scenera NEXT stand out from the rest. Not to mention, its simplistic design that’s rigged with enhanced features that you would normally find on high-end car seats.
Pros & Cons of Cosco Scenera NEXT
Pros
Cons
Who is the Cosco Scenera NEXT model best for?
If you’re looking for a basic car seat that’s equipped with slightly enhanced safety features, then the Scenera NEXT is a great choice. It’s also suitable for parents who travel a lot and need a car seat that can effortlessly make it through the airport.
Video Overview of Cosco Scenera NEXT
Our Rating: 67
Graco Size4Me 65 Safety Rating
The Size4me 65 receives an average score from Consumer Reports for its ease of installation in the rear-facing position and overall ease-of-use.
There are no NHTSA safety ratings for the Size4Me at this time.
Summary of Graco Size4Me 65
The Size4Me 65 offers superior protection in both the rear-facing and forward-facing positions. With its extended rear-facing weight range, your child will be able to ride in the rear-facing position longer. The Size4Me 65 is equipped with a SimplySafe Adjust harness system that lets you easily adjust both the harness and headrest at the same time. It’s outfitted in the machine-washable RapidRemove cover that can be effortlessly removed without uninstalling the car seat.
The Size4Me 65 is also equipped with the InRight latch system that reduces installation time. Also, the Size4Me 65 comes with a removable head and body pillow that maximizes comfort and keeps your baby snug. What makes The Size4Me 65 stand out is its innovative car seat cover that can be easily removed without uninstalling the car seat, saving you time and energy.
Pros & Cons of Graco Size4Me 65
Pros
Cons
Who is the Graco Size4Me 65 model best for?
The Size 4Me is a decent and well-made car seat with enhanced safety and installation features that will be suitable for most parents who are on a budget. It’s easy to use, clean, and install, and it will last for most of your child's car seat journey.
Video Overview of Graco Size4Me 65
17. Cybex Sirona
Our Rating: 60
Cybex Sirona Safety Rating
The Cybex Sirona receives a decent safety score from Consumer Reports. Where it lacks in seat belt installation, it makes up for it with its LATCH installation.
The Cybex Sirona earned low crash test results from Baby Gear Lab compared to its competition. However, it does meet the federal minimum safety regulations. It received high marks for its ease of installation using both a vehicle seatbelt and LATCH, overall ease-of-use, comfort, and quality.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 3 stars |
Securing the Child: | 3 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Summary of Cybex Sirona
The Cybex Sirona is engineered with superior safety features that work together to provide advanced protection for your little one. The Cybex Sirona integrates revolutionary safety technology into the chest clip of the car seat that monitors your child's well-being. This way, if problems arise, you’ll be alerted. It’s also equipped with a 12-position height-adjustable headrest that grows with your child and doesn't need to be rethreaded to adjust it.
What makes The Cybex Sirona stand out is its innovative and revolutionary child safety technology that alerts you when something is wrong with your little one. That, plus its other enhanced safety features set the Cybex Sirona apart from the rest.
Pros & Cons of Cybex Sirona
Pros
Cons
Who is the Cybex Sirona model best for?
The Cybex Sirona is best suited for parents who have a child with a medical condition. With its safety technology you’ll be altered when unsafe situations arise with your little one. It gives parents peace of mind while providing the ultimate protection for your little one.
Video Overview of Cybex Sirona
Our Rating: 58
Maxi Cosi Pria 85 Safety Rating
Consumer Reports gave the Pria 85 an average score with moderate to high marks for ease of installation.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Installation Features: | 2 stars | 2 stars |
Securing the Child: | 4 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Summary of Maxi Cosi Pria 85
The Pria 85 is designed to surround your child with the ultimate comfort and protection. It has a maximum weight limit of 85 pounds, so it could possibly be the last car seat you'll ever need. It’s equipped with a one-hand harness height adjustment that makes it very easy to adjust the harness without having to uninstall it. In addition to that, the Pria 85 is outfitted in machine-washable fabrics that can easily be removed without uninstalling the car seat.
What makes the Pria 85 stand out is its extended weight limit that surpasses other harnessed convertible car seats available on the market today.
Pros & Cons of Maxi Cosi Pria 85
Pros
Cons
Who is the Maxi Cosi Pria 85 model best for?
The Pria 85 is best suited for parents transitioning from an infant carrier to a convertible car seat. It’s a high-quality car seat, and it’s rigged with superior comfort features to create an enjoyable car riding experience every time your child rides in the car.
Video Overview of Maxi Cosi Pria 85
Our Rating: 55
Peg Perrigo Primo Viaggio Safety Rating
The Primo Viaggio receives an average score from Consumer Reports. It earned high marks for its ease of installation using LATCH, but the marks that it gets for seat belt installation brings the overall score down.
The Primo Viaggio earned an average score from Baby Gear Lab as well. Their crash tests showed that the Primo Viaggio meets the federal safety expectations but doesn't offer anything that makes its safety features stand out compared to its competition. It received high marks for its overall ease of use, comfort, and ease of installation using both a vehicle seat belt and LATCH.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Installation Features: | 3 stars | 4 stars |
Securing the Child: | 5 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 1 stars | 1 stars |
Summary of Peg Perrigo Primo Viaggio
The Primo Viaggio is an Italy-based car seat that provides the maximum safety for your little one using high-quality safety features. It’s outfitted in innovative Fresco Jersey fabrics that wick moisture and ventilates the car seat to keep your child cool, dry, and comfortable. The Primo Viaggio is equipped with a ten-position headrest that can be easily adjusted to provide a customized fit for your growing child.
Also, it’s engineered with a high-strength steel frame that reduces the impact forces on your child and redistributes them to the base of the car seat. Additionally, the Primo Viaggio features several recline positions that help you install the car seat at the most comfortable angle.
Pros & Cons of Peg Perrigo Primo Viaggio
Pros
Cons
Who is the Peg Perrigo Primo Viaggio model best for?
The Primo Viaggio is ideal for parents who want a car seat that’s specifically designed to offer superior safety and comfort. Although it’s very expensive, its high-quality design, ease of use, and premium fabrics make it well worth the price. However, I will say that its uninstallation features could be a bit better.
Video Overview of Peg Perrigo Primo Viaggio
Our Rating: 54
Safety 1st Guide 65 Safety Rating
The guide 65 earned an average score from Consumer Reports for its ease of installation in the forward-facing position. What brings the score down is its moderate to low marks for rear-facing installation.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 3 stars | 2 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 1 stars |
Securing the Child: | 3 stars | 2 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 5 stars | 3 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 5 stars | 5 stars |
Summary of Safety 1st Guide 65
The Guide 65 has a compact design that makes it a perfect first for smaller vehicles. It has an extended rear-facing weight range so that your child can ride in the rear-facing position longer. It’s equipped with a 5-point harness and up-front harness adjustment to make adjusting the harness quick and easy. The Guide 65 is also LATCH-equipped and comes with removable body pillows that keep your little one comfortable and supported. What’s special about the Guide 65 is its compact design that frees up enough room in the backseat that you could fit three across.
Pros & Cons of Safety 1st Guide 65
Pros
Cons
Who is the Safety 1st Guide 65 model best for?
The Guide 65 is best suited for parents that aren’t looking anything too fancy. It’s a simplistic car seat that’s proven to be safe and comes with standard safety and installation features that make it easy to use.
Video Overview of Safety 1st Guide 65
Our Rating: 50
Clek Foonf Safety Rating
Consumer Reports gives the Clek Foonf an average score for its overall ease of use. However, its lack in easy-to-use installation features brings the overall score down.
CSFTL recommends the Clek Foonf for its extended rear-facing weight range and compact design.
The Wirecutter recognizes the Clek Foonf for being easy to clean and having easy-to-use features. However, they also acknowledge the Clek Foonf for having serious drawbacks that knocked it out of the competition.
The Clek Foonf received average crash test results from Baby Gear Lab. It earned high marks for ease of installation with both a vehicle seat belt and LATCH, comfort, and quality.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 2 stars | 3 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 4 stars |
Securing the Child: | 2 stars | 2 stars |
Evaluation of Instruction: | 4 stars | 4 stars |
Evaluation of Labels: | 3 stars | 3 stars |
Summary of Clek Foonf
The Clek Foonf is a revolutionary car seat that’s rigged with superior safety features. It uses the innovative REACT Safety System that’s built into the car seat to actively reduce the impact forces of a collision. While most car seats use safety features towards the rear-facing position, the Clek Foonf utilizes features that drastically enhance forward-facing installation and safety. It has an extended rear-facing weight range that lets your child ride in the rear-facing position until their fourth birthday.
The Clek Foonf is equipped with an anti-rebound bar that minimizes the impact forces of a collision and makes installation easier and more secure. It also features the Rigid-LATCH System that makes forward-facing installation secure and accurate.
The REACT Safety System puts the Clek Foonf in a class of its own. Altogether, this system provides the ultimate protection for your little one while also making installation easier and more secure.
Pros & Cons of Clek Foonf
Pros
Cons
Who is the Clek Foonf model best for?
The Clek Foonf is specifically designed to provide superior protection and make installation safer and easier. If you have trouble and you can afford it, then the Clek Foonf is the car seat for you.
Video Overview of Clek Foonf
Our Rating: 47
Evenflo Tribute LX Safety Rating
The Tribute LX received an average score from Consumer Reports after its crash test results showed moderate to low rankings for ease of installation and overall ease of use.
The Tribute LX scored high as a result of the Baby Gear Labs crash tests. The test results showed that the Tribute LX added more safety features than its competitors, and it received a high mark for its lightweight design.
The NHTSA safety ratings are as follows:
Header | Rear-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings | Forward-Facing NHTSA Safety Ratings |
|---|---|---|
Overall Ease of Use: | 2 stars | 2 stars |
Installation Features: | 1 stars | 3 stars |
Securing the Child: | 2 stars |